Adobe’s Sam Garfield: AI has Sped Up Creative, But Organizations Haven’t Kept Pace

RANCHO PALOS VERDES, CALIF. — Creative ideation that once took weeks now takes days, and sometimes hours. Versioning an asset across channels, formats, and aspect ratios has sped up just as much. The slowdown has moved somewhere else.

According to Sam Garfield, head of Digital Strategy, CMT, Data and AI Platforms at Adobe, the friction now sits inside the enterprise operating model. AI works well within individual functions, and companies struggle to roll it out across workflows.

“58% of the companies we talk to are in what we call the frozen middle,” Garfield told Beet.TV contributor David Kaplan at Beet Retreat LA, citing Adobe’s research on organizational readiness. “That means they’re stuck in their AI deployment, either in a pilot or not being able to deploy at scale.”

Moving to the left

Garfield describes the creative process as a content supply chain, and AI is changing how it starts. A creative brief used to be a document. Now it can kick off the generation of creative and the pulling of an audience in a single automated workflow.

One Adobe customer summed up the goal for her team in a phrase Garfield liked. She wanted them to “move to the left,” toward strategy at the start of the process and away from production at the end.

“What we’re doing is helping teams move to the left,” Garfield said.

One-stop agencies

Asked whether agency value is shifting toward strategy, audience insight, data stewardship, or orchestration, Garfield answered “all of the above.” Agencies are collapsing the silos that once separated creative, media, and activation, and clients increasingly expect a single integrated offering. Adobe, he said, is the operating system many agencies are building on top of.

Data that doesn’t connect

Audience data exists, and so does creative effectiveness data. Garfield sees the challenge in joining the two. A Winterberry Group study Garfield mentioned found that every company surveyed is measuring creative effectiveness or planning to, but only 6% use it at every point in the process.

“The data exists, but connecting the data and making sure that’s flowing back into which audience you select and then through the creative for effectiveness measurement is not happening at scale,” Garfield said.

Governance by design

Garfield argues that brand safety and rights compliance can’t be a gate at the end of the process when AI moves this quickly. Adobe has built those capabilities into its products, including brand intelligence checks such as whether a generated asset places the logo correctly.

“We don’t look at governance as something that happens at the end, as sort of a gate at the end. It has to be designed as part of the feature set,” Garfield said.

RANCHO PALOS VERDES, CALIF. — Creative ideation that once took weeks now takes days, and sometimes hours. Versioning an asset across channels, formats, and aspect ratios has sped up just as much. The slowdown has moved somewhere else.

According to Sam Garfield, head of Digital Strategy, CMT, Data and AI Platforms at Adobe, the friction now sits inside the enterprise operating model. AI works well within individual functions, and companies struggle to roll it out across workflows.

“58% of the companies we talk to are in what we call the frozen middle,” Garfield told Beet.TV contributor David Kaplan at Beet Retreat LA, citing Adobe’s research on organizational readiness. “That means they’re stuck in their AI deployment, either in a pilot or not being able to deploy at scale.”

Moving to the left

Garfield describes the creative process as a content supply chain, and AI is changing how it starts. A creative brief used to be a document. Now it can kick off the generation of creative and the pulling of an audience in a single automated workflow.

One Adobe customer summed up the goal for her team in a phrase Garfield liked. She wanted them to “move to the left,” toward strategy at the start of the process and away from production at the end.

“What we’re doing is helping teams move to the left,” Garfield said.

One-stop agencies

Asked whether agency value is shifting toward strategy, audience insight, data stewardship, or orchestration, Garfield answered “all of the above.” Agencies are collapsing the silos that once separated creative, media, and activation, and clients increasingly expect a single integrated offering. Adobe, he said, is the operating system many agencies are building on top of.

Data that doesn’t connect

Audience data exists, and so does creative effectiveness data. Garfield sees the challenge in joining the two. A Winterberry Group study Garfield mentioned found that every company surveyed is measuring creative effectiveness or planning to, but only 6% use it at every point in the process.

“The data exists, but connecting the data and making sure that’s flowing back into which audience you select and then through the creative for effectiveness measurement is not happening at scale,” Garfield said.

Governance by design

Garfield argues that brand safety and rights compliance can’t be a gate at the end of the process when AI moves this quickly. Adobe has built those capabilities into its products, including brand intelligence checks such as whether a generated asset places the logo correctly.

“We don’t look at governance as something that happens at the end, as sort of a gate at the end. It has to be designed as part of the feature set,” Garfield said.