Wow: Bing Has Live Video Thumbnails — But is it Fair Use? (CORRECTED POST)

By on 06/01/2009 10:16 AM @beet_tv

Bing.2 One of the most striking aspects of Bing, the new search engine from Microsoft, is how it organizes video search results on a page of living thumbnails. 

So, unlike other video search which organizes still thumbnails and must be clicked to a destination to view, Bing somehow makes its thumbnails live by rolling over the image.

You can find a page of Beet.TV results on Bing right here.  I have pasted a still image of the results page here.

From a quick look, Bing pulls Beet.TV videos randomly from various sources where we syndicate including DailyMotion, Metacafe, MySpace, Google Video, YouTube and Yahoo!  You can watch the entire video as a thumbnail, with sound. 

If you click the thumbnail you go to secondary Bing page with the video.  The page does provide a link to the original source.

This is the broadest implementation of "universal video search" by a major company we have seen.  Yahoo! also surfaces videos from various sources and plays them on a Yahoo! video results page, but it does not have "moving thumbnails."  Blinkx provides thumbnail results as moving animated images, but they are real videos.

While this new platform for video search is very cool for users, I am not sure I can say the same for video producers or the video sharing sites.  Bing appears to pull a media RSS feed which is stripped of advertising overlays.  Not sure if this constitutes fair use or not, but it is something to explore.

Update 6/2:  Denise Howell, IP attorney who blogs on ZDNet weighs in, saying Microsoft is playing it fast and loose" with fair use.

Update/Correction 6/2:  In our excitement and haste about the movable thumbnails, we reported incorrectly that the thumbnails play the whole video with audio.  Our error: It provides extended excerpts, not the whole thing.  This feature is very cool and unique but is probably within the bounds of fair use. Our apologies.

Update/New Post 6/3 — See my interview with Bing Director Stefan Weitz.

Last week at D: All Things Digital, I spoke with CNET News.com's Ina Fried and TechCrunch's Erick Schonfeld on what is different about Bing and some of its challenges.  The video is below.

Andy Plesser, Executive Producer

Recent Videos
image
AdTech Firms Need to Adhere to Attribution Standards, Group M Says

CANNES — Agencies like Group M are requiring that technology partners adhere to baseline standards when it comes to the measurement area of attribution modeling, says Cary Tilds, Chief Innovation Officer at Group M, in this interview with Beet.TV. “The one single thing I see in new technology ...

image
Bankoff Wants Vox’s Video On Mobile And Everywhere

CANNES — Vox Media‘s portfolio of eight sites may be pretty popular on their own. Together, the publisher claims around 170 million monthly uniques for the collection, to which it recently added Re/code. But CEO Jim Bankoff is thinking bigger. He wants to spread that content off from just owned ...

image
Mondelēz’s Bough Wants To Build Bigger, Better, Faster “Unicorns”

CANNES — Brands buying ads that drive traffic to wholesale retailers will push ecommerce to new heights, according to the marketing chief of Oreo and Toblerone company Mondelēz International. Bonin Bough reckons a coming fusion of media buying and ecommerce opportunities will fuel massive business ...

image
SMG Adds Video and Native Distribution to Content@Scale Program

CHICAGO — SMG is expanding the content platform it launched early last year to encompass video and native distribution channels. Designed to help SMG clients with their content marketing efforts, Content@Scale gives quick access to licensed content produced by more than 36 publishers and 135 content ...

image
On Daily Mail’s TV Show, ‘The Site Is The Star': Steinberg

CANNES — Almost exactly a year after the president and chief operating officer of BuzzFeed was named to lead MailOnline’s US expansion as the online paper’s north America CEO, now Jon Steinberg is already enjoying getting a toehold in to the TV business. At Cannes Lions, DailyMail.com (as ...

image
Daily Mail, Dr. Phil Consummate Story Sharing With TV Show Marriage

CANNES — Late 2015 and early 2016 already look like shaping up to be the time when the biggest online media brands try breaking in to the old medium of TV. AOL already hopes to gain distribution for its new HuffPo Show weekly satirical show, and BuzzFeed is known to be considering its options. Now ...

image
Shane Smith on Vice, Brands, Pinterest & Video For Millennials

CANNES — How should a financial giant market to young adults in the digital age? By giving it to them straight. That’s according to Vice Media CEO Shane Smith, whose publishing company us helping Bank Of America do just that. At Cannes Lions, the bank announced the launch of The Business Of Life, ...

image
IPG’s Cadreon to Launch Automated TV Ad Platform with TubeMogul in July

CANNES – Cadreon, the digital marketing platform of IPG Mediabrands, will introduce its programmatic TV buying platform created in partnership with TubeMogul, next month with its first campaigns, says Arun Kumar, Global President, in this interview with Beet.TV Kumar says that the new platform has been ...

image
Goodby: Addressable TV Ads Will Feel Like “They Were Made Just For You”

CANNES — Addressable TV and the notion of targeting TV ads individually has been a hot topic in the ad industry for years, and it may very soon be scaleable. “We’ll be able to make it so that it feels like it was just made for you,” says Jeff Goodby, co-chairman at Goodby, Silverstein & ...

image
GroupM’s Gotlieb Says Reviews Often Happen When Agencies ‘Over-Promise’

CANNES — According to GroupM Chairman Irwin Gotlieb, many media reviews are happening at least in part because of a bad habit agencies have developed of promising too much. “Everything comes home to roost eventually,” says Gotlieb in an interview with BeetTV at Cannes this week. “Those who ...

image
‘Under Siege': Kawaja On How Mad Men Are Fighting Back

CANNES — It’s a mad, mad, mad, mad world if you’re an ad agency exec right now. On the one hand, you have a palette of unlimited possibility at your fingertips – on the other hand, so does everybody else. Renowned media and technology M&A advisor and banker Terence Kawaja of Luma ...

image
Advertising Must Get Back To Creativity: Starcom’s Richman

CANNES — These days in ad land, it seems like the only topic in town is data. The transformative potential of data-driven tools has spawned a plethora of advertising technology platforms, allowing buyers to sellers to better mediate the trading and targeting of messages. For an industry that has always ...

loader