Wow: Bing Has Live Video Thumbnails — But is it Fair Use? (CORRECTED POST)

By on 06/01/2009 10:16 AM @beet_tv

Bing.2 One of the most striking aspects of Bing, the new search engine from Microsoft, is how it organizes video search results on a page of living thumbnails. 

So, unlike other video search which organizes still thumbnails and must be clicked to a destination to view, Bing somehow makes its thumbnails live by rolling over the image.

You can find a page of Beet.TV results on Bing right here.  I have pasted a still image of the results page here.

From a quick look, Bing pulls Beet.TV videos randomly from various sources where we syndicate including DailyMotion, Metacafe, MySpace, Google Video, YouTube and Yahoo!  You can watch the entire video as a thumbnail, with sound. 

If you click the thumbnail you go to secondary Bing page with the video.  The page does provide a link to the original source.

This is the broadest implementation of "universal video search" by a major company we have seen.  Yahoo! also surfaces videos from various sources and plays them on a Yahoo! video results page, but it does not have "moving thumbnails."  Blinkx provides thumbnail results as moving animated images, but they are real videos.

While this new platform for video search is very cool for users, I am not sure I can say the same for video producers or the video sharing sites.  Bing appears to pull a media RSS feed which is stripped of advertising overlays.  Not sure if this constitutes fair use or not, but it is something to explore.

Update 6/2:  Denise Howell, IP attorney who blogs on ZDNet weighs in, saying Microsoft is playing it fast and loose" with fair use.

Update/Correction 6/2:  In our excitement and haste about the movable thumbnails, we reported incorrectly that the thumbnails play the whole video with audio.  Our error: It provides extended excerpts, not the whole thing.  This feature is very cool and unique but is probably within the bounds of fair use. Our apologies.

Update/New Post 6/3 — See my interview with Bing Director Stefan Weitz.

Last week at D: All Things Digital, I spoke with CNET News.com's Ina Fried and TechCrunch's Erick Schonfeld on what is different about Bing and some of its challenges.  The video is below.

Andy Plesser, Executive Producer

Recent Videos
image
Data Can Be Used as a ‘Consumer Fingerprint’, SMG’s Simpson

LONDON — Data is rooted in numbers, but the use of it is most effective when brands view data as a “consumer fingerprint,” says Steve Simpson, Exec VP and Global Managing Director of Digital Strategy, Data and Analytics at SMG, in an interview with Beet.TV. “Think about it as a ...

image
Vice Sees Huge Upside for News Operation, Brian Dietz Tells Beet.TV

In just the past six month, Vice has become “one of the biggest newscasts in the country and possibly the world,” says Vice SVP for sales Brian Dietz in this segment on Beet.TV.  Dietz tells our Ashley Swartz that Vice news has some 650K subscribers on YouTube and has had 70 million videos ...

Ashley Swartz, Furious Minds 2
VOD Could Shepherd More Programmatic Buying in TV, Ashley Swartz

Video-on-demand inventory is the next logical entry point for programmatic style advertising into linear TV, says Ashley J. Swartz, CEO and Founder of Furious Minds, in an interview with Beet.TV. “VOD is the first inventory that will come online for dynamic ad insertion,” she says. “The ...

image
Razorfish Media Chief Kathuria on Scale, TV Dollars, and Big Data

Moving TV dollars to online remains a challenge says Vik Kathuria, Global Chief Media Officer at Razorfish in an interview with Beet.TV. “It’s very hard to find an apples to apples comparison in terms of TV money and where to move it. If you are a TV buyer, you want to scale. To effectively move ...

Steve Parker, SMG UK
Programmatic Poised to Impact TV Buying, SMG’s Steve Parker says

LONDON — Programmatic advertising not only has the potential to influence digital advertising, but also TV, says Steve Parker, co-CEO of Starcom MediaVest Group in London, in an interview with Beet.TV. “What we’re learning around programmatic video allows us to transform our relationship ...

image
More Agencies to Launch Private Exchanges, Zenith’s Zilberbrand

As programmatic buying expands, look for agencies to build more private marketplaces in the next 12 to 18 months, says Julian Zilberbrand, EVP Activation Standards, Insights, & Technology at ZenithOptimedia Group in an interview with Beet.TV. That’s because private exchanges provide an ecosystem ...

image
Programmatic TV Buying on the Horizon

Programmatic advertising has flourished digitally, but in time it will spread further to TV, says Brendan Condon, CEO of Media Property Holdings, which operates like an ad network but for TV buying by aggregating TV spend across multichannel video providers, syndicators and local broadcasters. But there are ...

image
Ad Tech Lets Advertisers Run Their Own Show: MediaMath’s Cox

Larger advertisers are beginning to realize that, with a range of new online technology, they can disintermediate their agencies to take more control of their own campaign spending, says an ad tech exec. “We’re seeing an increase in operators wanting to run their own marketing programs directly using ...

image
2014 Is ‘The Year Of Private Marketplaces’: BrightRoll’s Avila

The next stage in the adoption of  automated ad-trading tools, private marketplaces are helping so-called “programmatic” practices flourish, says an exec in the space. “If 2013 was the year of real-time bidding and programmatic coming in to reality, 2014 is the year of private ...

Stefan Maris, Civolution
Publishers May Soon Sell TV-Synced Ads: Civolution’s Maris

Nowadays, advertisers are starting to buy ads in social media streams that are synchronized with TV ads. Soon, they may also get to buy display ads on premium publisher sites in the same way. “2014 was all about getting the pipes in place,” says Stefan Maris, global product manager of Civolution, ...

image
“Utopia” Of Programmatic TV is Getting Closer: TubeMogul’s Eadie

The holy grail of mass-market TV through which advertisers can target individual viewers is coming nearer as better and better ad tech improves prospects, says one company playing in this emerging area. “We obviously don’t have that utopic state in linear TV right now,” says TubeMogul CMO Keith ...

image
Key Focus for Programmatic Should Be Business Outcomes, Razorfish’s Kathuria

The key focus of programmatic buying should be on delivering business outcomes for a marketer, says Vik Kathuria, Global Chief Media Officer at Razorfish in an interview with Beet.TV. If an agency can do that, then it makes sense to keep programmatic buying in house, he says. In the coming year, he predicts ...

loader