Craig Newmark: I Didn’t Kill Newspapers, it’s an “urban legend” and David Carr Agrees

By on 06/03/2009 8:51 PM @beet_tv

Caught up with Craig Newmark, founder of craigslist immediately after his panel organized by iWantMedia today in Manhattan.  

He told me that while his company has had "an effect on newspapers," the notion that it has killed newspapers is "urban legend."

New York Times media columnist David Carr was on hand at the event.  After I spoke with Newmark, I asked David if Craig killed newspapers. He said the list shot their "back-end off" but didn't blame Newmark.

If you haven't watched one-hour the panel, check it out. It's great to watch Nick Denton and Wall Street Journal Deputy Managing Editor Allan Murray go at. Newmark is a hoot. This was shot at the NYU TV studio and streamed via Livestream.  It is running in a realtime loop here (scroll down the page to see the player.)

Patrick-phillips Congratulations to Patrick Phillips, founder of iWantMedia for putting together such a superb program and doing such an ace job at moderating.

Andy Plesser, Executive Producer

Here's the take on our Newmark interview up on Mediabistro.

You can find Beet.TV on the Huffington Post too!

Video Transcript


Andy Plesser: 
Craig, so you talked about the newspapers. Craigslist has not killed the newspapers.

Craig Newmark:  I…You know we have an effect on newspapers; to a large extent it's an urban legend. In a democracy you just got to have a vital press with a journalist asking tough questions and then getting answers.

Andy Plesser:  What's next developments for Craig's list do you think?

Craig Newmark:  You know, for us it's mostly more of the same: more cities, more countries, maybe more languages. That's about it.

Andy Plesser:  Let me ask you about Craig. He said that Craigslist has not killed the newspapers; it's an urban legend.  Is it an urban legend or did Craigslist kill the newspapers? Well, I mean, not that they're dead, some of them are.

David Carr:  Well they've shot the back end off of newspapers, but if Craig wouldn't have done it, somebody else would've. I think having Craig is Colonel Mustard having committed murder against…I think that's over and done. The newspaper industry has significant audience problems that they need to address that have nothing to do with Craig or Craigslist.

Recent Videos
image
Facebook Targeting A Boon for Marketers, Havas’ Social Lead

CHICAGO — Facebook is a marketer’s dream for video, but brands need to be smart about how to use the targeting, fan base, and types of video on the social network, says Len Kendall, Director of Social Marketing at Havas Worldwide, in an interview with Beet.TV. “Because of segmentation and ...

image
Ziff Davis Enjoying ‘Renaissance’: CEO Shah

When Vivek Shah took over at the helm of PCMag.com publisher Ziff Davis, the company was still recovering after emerging from Chapter 11 bankruptcy protection, continuing to sell off properties. If he says so himself, Ziff Davis under Shah may has turned a corner. “Ziff is probably one of the more ...

image
Comcast Sees Big Growth in C3 VOD Viewing

While TV Everywhere tends to dominates the chatter about non-linear viewing, many cablers are actively marketing and delivering viewers for their existing VOD services. Comcast, for instance, logged its 30 billionth program viewed on demand in the last year and has seen 100% growth in time spent viewing in ...

image
Passion, Entertainment, Education Key To Brand Video: BPN’s Hiland

CHICAGO — What are the key ingredients to a making a video that works both as editorial and marketing? One big barbecue food maker mixed entertainment, education and a healthy dose of passion. IPG’s BPN chief strategy officer Chris Hiland tells Beet.TV in this recorded panel interview how his ...

image
Video Beats Display, Nearly As Good As TV: comScore’s Fulgoni

CHICAGO — Digital video is performing highly as an advertising medium, and nearly approaching the volume of TV in some quarters, says one of the leaders of venerable media metrics house comScore. “You need about three times as many display impressions to get to the same lift in impact which you ...

image
IAB’s Shah: Too Many Viewability Platforms Will Hurt Industry

Viewability, the recently-defined metric that defines whether an online ad slot is really viewable by consumers is a wholesale change for the industry – but its benefits may be blunted as too many platforms are vying to help advertisers capitalize, according to Ziff Davis CEO and IAB chair Vivek Shah. ...

image
Marketers Can Reach ‘Meerkats’ With Mobile: Weather Channel’s Dan Young

LONDON — Mobile video heralds a chance for advertisers to reach consumers who may appear to be distracted or in the outdoors – but who are actually highly engaged and watching TV, according to Weather Channel international yield and programmatic Daniel Young. “It’s personal,” Young ...

image
Ooyala Buying Videoplaza To Enhance Video Advertising Breadth

They are two of the best-known names in online video service provision – and now they are coming together as one. Video streaming service Ooyala, itself now owned by Australian telco Telstra, is acquiring its video advertising peer Videoplaza. The buying company says the deal “allows Ooyala to ...

image
Videology Opens TV Practice To Make Buying Smarter

Videology has established a strong profile for itself by helping TV ad buyers make intelligent decisions to buy online video ads. Now it wants to help them buy good old fashioned TV ads in the same way. The New York-based company is opening a dedicated TV practice. As CEO Scott Ferber tells The Wall Street ...

image
Interstitial Better Than Auto-Play: Jun CEO Mulls New Mobile Ads

CHICAGO – Ad network Jun Group’s CEO Mitchell Reichgut “recoils” when he hears about auto-playing ads, the new format being picked by Facebook and others to deliver video messages. But that doesn’t mean he won’t try introducing interruptive ads of his own. ...

image
Facebook is Redefining the Value of of Video Autoplay, Vivek Shah

Historically, videos which start automatically on Web pages and in mobile apps can be offensive to users, but the approach taken by Facebook by setting videos to autoplay without sound, is an important step forward for publishers and marketers, says Vivek Shah, chairman of the IAB and CEO of Ziff Davis, in ...

image
Mindshare’s Cridlin to Brands: Stop Seeking Fans on Facebook — “Organic Reach Is Non-Existent”

CHICAGO – Put your money where your mouth is. That’s the new mantra of digital ad execs who believe gaining free audiences by building viral social audiences is over. “There is an urban myth of organic reach, of something going viral,” Mindshare digital innovation and strategy MD Jim ...

loader