Craig Newmark: I Didn’t Kill Newspapers, it’s an “urban legend” and David Carr Agrees

By on 06/03/2009 8:51 PM @beet_tv

Caught up with Craig Newmark, founder of craigslist immediately after his panel organized by iWantMedia today in Manhattan.  

He told me that while his company has had "an effect on newspapers," the notion that it has killed newspapers is "urban legend."

New York Times media columnist David Carr was on hand at the event.  After I spoke with Newmark, I asked David if Craig killed newspapers. He said the list shot their "back-end off" but didn't blame Newmark.

If you haven't watched one-hour the panel, check it out. It's great to watch Nick Denton and Wall Street Journal Deputy Managing Editor Allan Murray go at. Newmark is a hoot. This was shot at the NYU TV studio and streamed via Livestream.  It is running in a realtime loop here (scroll down the page to see the player.)

Patrick-phillips Congratulations to Patrick Phillips, founder of iWantMedia for putting together such a superb program and doing such an ace job at moderating.

Andy Plesser, Executive Producer

Here's the take on our Newmark interview up on Mediabistro.

You can find Beet.TV on the Huffington Post too!

Video Transcript


Andy Plesser: 
Craig, so you talked about the newspapers. Craigslist has not killed the newspapers.

Craig Newmark:  I…You know we have an effect on newspapers; to a large extent it's an urban legend. In a democracy you just got to have a vital press with a journalist asking tough questions and then getting answers.

Andy Plesser:  What's next developments for Craig's list do you think?

Craig Newmark:  You know, for us it's mostly more of the same: more cities, more countries, maybe more languages. That's about it.

Andy Plesser:  Let me ask you about Craig. He said that Craigslist has not killed the newspapers; it's an urban legend.  Is it an urban legend or did Craigslist kill the newspapers? Well, I mean, not that they're dead, some of them are.

David Carr:  Well they've shot the back end off of newspapers, but if Craig wouldn't have done it, somebody else would've. I think having Craig is Colonel Mustard having committed murder against…I think that's over and done. The newspaper industry has significant audience problems that they need to address that have nothing to do with Craig or Craigslist.

Recent Videos
image
BSkyB Plans Bigger Footprint For ‘AdSmart’ Addressable TV

LONDON – British satellite TV and telco operator BSkyB hopes its AdSmart technology – one of the world’s largest real-world deployments of addressable TV – will soon extend to more TV channels and more countries. Launched in January after lengthy gestation, AdSmart sees different ads ...

image
Buying TV And Video Improves Campaigns: Amnet’s Hobson

LONDON — In the online advertising industry, many professionals expect advertisers to start moving some of their TV ad budgets in to the fast-growing world of online video, where metrics give them more visible insight in to effectiveness. But not everyone sees the trend as an “either-or”. ...

image
Australia, Europe Lead Private Programmatic Marketplace Adoption, Adap.tv’s Duffield

LONDON — Private-marketplaces, the next generation of programmatic ad-trading platforms, are gaining traction more quickly outside of the United States, as markets work to make up for relatively fewer available ad spots, according to a global video ad tech exec. “A market like Australia is a ...

image
Joining The Dots Is About To Get Hot: Acxiom’s Howe

COLOGNE — So much data, so many new ad tech platforms. Anyone who has seen a lumascape will recognize the confusion that fragmentation wreaks. But there is a way to pull the piece back together, says an ad tech boss. “One of the key buzzwords that we’re going to be hearing about over and ...

image
Programmatic Could Fuel All Media Insights: SpotXchange’s Merwin

COLOGNE — So far, “programmatic” mechanisms for using automation and data to buy better ads have proved useful in the online display segment. Next up, they are destined to change online video ads. But, in the future, Alex Merwin envisages programmatic underpinning entire cross-media ad ...

Amanda Richman, Starcom 1
Starcom’s Amanda Richman Sees Programmatic Expanding To More Channels

One of the biggest opportunities with programmatic lies in using it as a starting point to bring targeting and data efficiency to all channels, including TV, says Amanda Richman, President, Investment and Activation, Starcom USA in an interview with Beet.TV. “Some see programmatic as real-time ...

image
AOL Grows Programmatic Business Year Over Year, Bob Lord

AOL has seen a boost in programmatic buying from 4% a year ago to nearly 34%, says Bob Lord, Global CEO of AOL Platforms, in an interview with Beet.TV. That growth is driven by two trends — more understanding of the benefits of programmatic buying, and the availability of data management platforms to ...

image
Martin Sorrell: Investment in AppNexus Allows WPP to Compete with Google and Facebook

With its recent investment and technology exchange with AppNexus, WPP will  have the technology platform to compete against companies like Google’s DoubleClick and Facebook’s Atlas, says Sir Martin Sorrell, WPP chief executive, in this interview with Beet.TV  He says that Google and Facebook ...

image
Data Gives Agencies Leverage Over Networks: Carat’s Ray

LONDON — The emerging plethora of TV viewer data being pumped out by third-party agencies and new measurement models is giving ad agencies and their clients a leg-up when it comes to negotiating the buying of TV ad spots, says one agency boss. “Because of that data warehouse you’re starting ...

image
Nearly Half Of Digital Display Now Sold Programmatically: Magna Global

So-called “programmatic” software platforms, which let advertising buyers and sellers agree terms for ad inventory in real-time and using customer data, will process $21 billion global ad sales in 2014, according to new forecasts from IPG’s Magna Global intelligence unit. That is 52% more ...

image
‘Digital Media’ Are Behind Us: Starcom MediaVest’s Sheehy

COLOGNE — As media platforms and the processes behind them converge, old definitions of each appear to fall away and become meaningless. That, at least, goes for advertising groups that are getting excited about defining the internet in TV’s likeness. “I think ‘digital media’ maybe a ...

image
Converged Video Buying ‘Won’t Happen Overnight’: Mediaocean’s Johnston

COLOGNE — Video advertising technology platforms are helping advertisers and agencies on the road to buying online video and television ads in a single process – but don’t expect that process to be widespread in the immediate future. “TV is still very dominant,” agency ad-buying ...

loader