Madison Avenue’s Frustration with Online Video: Quality is “Complete Crap,” top WPP Exec

By on 11/06/2009 6:46 AM @beet_tv

Despite the commanding position of YouTube, with 40 percent of video streams in the U.S., the quality of the environment for advertisers is not always acceptable, according to leading digital advertising executives.

Rob Norman, CEO of WPP’s giant GroupM Interaction, the digital media buying group, says that despite the availability of high quality video ads to go up on the Web, the technical quality and environment of sites like YouTube is not acceptable. He says the current environment is “complete crap.”  (His comments come at the end of this clip.)

GroupM says it is the world’s largest media buying company, with billings of $60 billion.

Ogilvy’s Robert Davis and Digitas’ John McCarus discuss the value of YouTube as a powerful distribution platform with value and limitations.

YouTube has recently increased the number of pre-roll ads and has expanded its relationship with many ad agencies.

This is an excerpt from last month’s Beet.TV Online Video Roundtable held at the New York offfices of 

Moderating this section is Michael Learmonth, reporter for Advertising Age.  Michael recently reported how consumer package goods are using online video advertising in a big way.

Andy Plesser, Executive Producer

Video Transcript

Michael Learmonth:  Eric Smith said yesterday or the day before that YouTube is now doing business with 90 of the top 100 AdAge, top advertisers. What are your clients saying about YouTube? What, if anything, are they doing on YouTube, and do you think YouTube has figured out the scalable model that’s going to work for them?

John McCarus: 
Well, I would say for Digitas and the Third Act, which is our brand content platform, that we’re very much working with YouTube as a distribution partner. I think one of the challenges is they spent some time trying to dabble in the content business and I’m not so sure if that’s an area where they can see a lot of sucess.

Michael Learmonth:
  Well, they had one big go with that, right? And they said they were going to do more and it just didn’t happen.

John McCarus:  Yeah, and look, they’re a terrific distribution network and a terrific technology platform and what we have to remember on the web is that, unlike in broadcast television, we have the opportunity and challenge for packaging all of this ourselves as clients and advertisers. It is, with the right thinking, successful and many times the best solution. So we are putting YouTube together with the right content solutions and have actually some big programs that will be announced shortly.

Robert Davis:  Yeah, I think, you know, not to comment on their business model, that’s whatever they try to do, they try to do, right? Now, it’s essential. They own so much of the market that it’s essential for clients to be there, to be well represented. Are they the end-all, be-all? No, but they own 40% of the views, so you deal with them and then you deal with the other 60% as you can.

What I see as I look around at YouTube though, is that it’s not being used to its fullest extent. I’m amazed at the poor quality of video that’s being posted. And that’s not YouTube’s fault, that’s the fault of the people putting up the video…

Michael Learmonth:  Well it’s their fault that they don’t surface the good stuff, right?

Robert Davis:  Well no, just even technical quality, forget even content. I’m just looking at it, going, “If somebody put that on TV looking that way, they’d be fired.” Why is it acceptable? Full gamut. Why is that acceptable online? So I think there’s things that we, as an industry, need to start realizing that YouTube is probably more powerful than we’re making itself.

Rob Norman:  So it’s maybe ironic when you look at YouTube, and we’ve now got this host of HD delivery systems. If you actually looked up, it’s possible that today is lower proportion of all video that’s consumed is consumed at the highest possible quality that was available than ever before. Because, although we’ve got HD and we’ve got a whole load of ads in HD, we’ve also got millions and millions of pieces of video being consumed in a customer delivery quality that’s complete crap. It’s kind of interesting.

Recent Videos
Context And Audience Go Hand-In-Hand: Xaxis’ Beaumier

The coming age in which TV adverts can be distributed to different individual viewers based on specific targeting criteria could, in theory, mean an end to the practice of buying ads against particular shows known to pull broad audience demographics. But one ad tech exec doesn’t expect a wholesale ...

Cord-Cutting Is Forcing Smarter TV Ad Offerings: AT&T’s Brown

The emerging prospect of targeting individual TV viewers with ads, no matter what show or channel they’re watching, may be real – but that doesn’t mean the industry should throw out the old practice of buying ads in shows considered to have demographic matches. That’s according ...

Upfronts Won’t Die In TV Renaissance: Magna Global’s Bayer

FORT LAUDERDALE — If you think the coming age of buying addressable, internet-style ads in the blink of an eye is going to mean an end to the TV ad industry as we know it, think again. “I think we’ve entered …a renaissance of television,” Matt Bayer, SVP of advanced TV at Magna ...

Brienna Pinnow, Experian
Experian Gearing To Launch Connected Addressable TV Platform

FORT LAUDERDALE — “This has really been the year of addressable TV. We’ve done literally triple the amount of work compared to 2014,” according to Experian addressable advertising product lead Brienna Pinnow. Now the data company wants to do more? But what exactly? “To develop ...

More Safeguards Needed For Dynamic Ad Creative: Bank of America’s Paskalis

The concept of dynamic ad insertion – through which, consumers would get served a brand ad with different content, depending on their targeting profile – has been talked about for a couple of years now. The exciting reality may be around the corner, if the industry can persuade brands it is a ...

Context Of Viewing Still Matters To Ads: Videology’s CEO

Now that online video ad targeting technology can reach advertisers’ ideal audiences wherever they are watching, what is the use for the old model, in which buyers place their bets on shows with audiences they believed to be matched? The new doesn’t have to trump the old, says video ad tech ...

Too Soon For Dynamic Creative Ads: DISH’s Gaynor

Super-targeted TV advertising is just around the corner, but don’t expect the content of those ads to be served dynamically just yet. That’s according to DISH media sales and analytics VP Adam Gaynor. In this video interview with Beet.TV, he says: “Advertisers no longer need to use ...

Castree On Videology’s “Sand, Rocks & Boulders”

FORT LAUDERDALE — It’s one of the major ad tech vendors promising to define the emerging video advertising space. But what is going on at Videology lately? The way North America MD Tim Castree describes, Videology is a little bit like geology… “Sand — How we can use our ...

Cut The Fraud Bull From Ad Pricing: GroupM’s Gotlieb

If you want to price digital advertising appropriately, don’t just look at the rapidly-growing supply of inventory, look beneath the surface for what is really real. That’s according to veteran ad exec Irwin Gotlieb, the chairman of ad group GroupM. “Supply measured without taking in to ...

Context Still Matters For TV Ads: FreeWheel’s Rothwell

Does the coming age of one-to-one, super-personalized TV ads make the traditional process of buying ads against shows of a particular type dead in the water? Not at all, says FreeWheel agency and brand relations VP James Rothwell, whose company helps place video ads. “Context still matters,” ...

Data Will Set Context Free: SMG’s Scheppach

Advertisers are getting excited by the possibilities for super-targeted TV marketing promised by new ad tech platforms. In fact, to many, it looks like the days of traditional TV ads, which are bought against the context of demographic audience profiles, are numbered. But things are set for a correction, ...

How Simulmedia Tracks The ROI Of Linear TV: VP Storan

FORT LAUDERDALE — It may be old-fashioned linear TV, but that doesn’t mean you can’t bring internet-like next-gen ad measurement to the ‘ol box. That’s what Simulmedia, the ad technology vendor, is doing. Although the company focuses on helping clients find the best inventory ...